Fairy Tale Villain Unit Study

Not all fairy tales have villains, but many do. Here’s a list of fairy tale villains with links to the lesson plans we have here at FreshPlans for those fairy tales. By and large, we don’t talk much about the villains. But there is right now a trend toward making movies and books about the villains, giving their back stories and all the reasons they became villains.

In fairy tales, the villains don’t need reasons. While people in the fairy tales sometimes behave badly, the actual villains are just evil. That’s why they act like that: it’s in their natures.

However, it can be interesting and instructive to study the villains. Here are some cross-curricular lesson plans for all ages.

English: Point of view

Understanding point of view is important for reading stories, but it also matters when reading nonfiction and even news reports. Fairy tales are told in the third person, as though the narrator were a disinterested observer. In fact, the stories may be seen mostly from the point of view of the hero or the victim of the villain.

The story of Rumpelstitlskin is one in which every character behaves in morally questionable ways. Rumpelstiltskin uses the miller’s daughter’s predicament to get jewelry from her and then to extort a promise to give him her firstborn child, so he is often seen as the villain. But the miller brags and lies about his daughter, and then hands her over to the king. The king shuts the daughter up in a room and forces her to spin straw into gold, offering her nothing but marriage to her captor, and threatening her with execution. The girl never stands up for herself, marries her abuser, and agrees to give up her child even though she never intends to do so. Basically, everybody behaved badly.

Every character has his or her own point of view. Their background and experience, the effects on them of others’ behavior, and their prejudices and biases give them a different perception of the events. This can be true of news reports (especially very personal news reports such as the TikTok news that many young people rely on these days), books and articles analyzing information, blog posts, and people’s oral reports of events. Recognizing point of view is an essential skill for critical reading.

Choose a book or books written about a fairy tale from a different point of view:

 

For Real, I Paraded in My Underpants!: The Story of the Emperor’s New Clothes as Told by the Emperor

After reading the variants, choose a villain from a different story. Download and fill out the Fairy Tale Villains Worksheet  

Have kids write the story from the villain’s point of view.  Kids could write this in the form of a diary, an exposé, or a supporter explaining how the fairy tale got it wrong. For the youngest students, dictating their idea and having someone write down what they say should count.

Social studies: Justice for the villain

Choose a fairy tale and identify the laws that might have been broken in the story. Some resources:

For example, in Rapunzel, we can see that Rapunzel’s father trespassed, stole produce from the witch, and sold his child for vegetables (human trafficking). In addition, the witch kidnapped and unlawfully imprisoned Rapunzel, and the prince trespassed on the witch’s property.

Have kids  choose whom to prosecute, draw up a police report, and prepare statements from the prosecution and defense for the trial. For a group of kids, choose students to play the judge, the defendant, the lawyers, the jury, and the police officer. Hold a mock trial.

Challenge kids to write a news story about the trial.

Critical thinking: Evidence

Looking at either the trial or an alternate point of view story, consider what really constitutes evidence. For example, Little Red Riding Hood saw that her granny had big ears, big eyes, and big teeth — bigger than her granny’s features would have been. She also heard the wolf say, “The better to eat you with , my dear!”, which seems like a threat. These could certainly be evidence that it was the Big Bad Wolf conspiring g to eat the little girl.

On the other hand, the evidence against the giant in “Jack and the Beanstalk” is a bit thin. While he does threaten to grind the bones of the Englishman whom he smells and to make the ground bones into bread, he doesn’t specify Jack in particular. Jack might be the villain in that story.

Let each kid choose one story, or work as a group to gather evidence against a group, such as trolls, ogres, and giants or witches, both of whom show up in multiple stories as villains. Find, list, and evaluate the evidence and decide whether the supposed villains are wrongly accused or fairly condemned.

print

Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.